Would You Pay for a Ferrari If You Only Needed a Tractor?

Buying more system than the business needs is a choice with a running cost, not a safe default.

A couple of years ago, I led a project that exposed a hard truth: just because an ERP is "industry-aligned" doesn’t mean it’s right for your business.

A large organization—responsible for finance, project funding, and governance - had been sold a top-tier ERP designed for complex supply chains, logistics, and asset-heavy operations. On paper, it sounded perfect.

The Sales Pitch they got?

"Best practice for your industry" – A system built for large-scale operations
"Future-proofing" – A scalable ERP that could grow with them
"Trusted by industry leaders" – Because if the big players use it, it must be good, right?

The Reality Check:

Only 25 people used it – just Finance & the Portfolio & Program Office (PPO)
No supply chain, no production, no asset tracking – just budgets and funding
The total cost? Likely well over seven figures when factoring in licensing, implementation, and ongoing maintenance

They had been sold on a dream, but the reality was a bloated, expensive system that didn’t align with how they actually operated.

What We Did Instead:

Right-sized their ERP – migrated them to a leaner, cost-effective solution
Eliminated bloated costs & unnecessary modules, saving hundreds of thousands
Automated Accounts Payable, cutting out slow, manual processes
Simplified reporting & data management, turning spreadsheets into real-time insights

The Result?

Significant cost savings – freeing up budget for actual business initiatives
A system that fit their business needs, not just their industry’s "best practices"
Faster decision-making, fewer IT headaches – real efficiency, not just expensive software

The Hard Truth About ERP Migrations

Was it all smooth sailing? Hell no!

ERP migrations are never easy. This one had its share of headaches, resistance, and the joy of untangling years of IT decisions. But in the end, the impact was clear:

They went from burning money on an oversized system to having the right tech at the right price – without sacrificing capability.
We proved that "industry best practice" means nothing if it doesn’t align with business reality.
And most importantly, we delivered real value, not just another IT bill.

Final Thought: Is Your ERP a Ferrari or a Tractor?

Because in business, it’s not about having the biggest tools – it’s about getting the best results.

What’s the most overpriced software you’ve ever used?

ALSO IN THE REGISTER